Description:
David Gibbs, a war historian at the University of Arizona, tells Zulfiqar Ali that Trump cannot win the war in Iran and cannot walk away without a defeat he could not survive politically. Gibbs argues that leaves escalation, a decision the US system gives to one man, and that Trump is not the exception but the rule in America's presidential wars. Ali brings a readout from Iranian contacts: Trump is "95% ready" to strike again after the midterms.
On 15 October President Trump said he would not use nuclear weapons against Iran. Gibbs's view of what happens if a renewed strike fails is his analysis. He also sees an even greater nuclear risk in Ukraine.
The 95% and 99% figures, and the account of Iran's preparations, are the host's own sourcing from Iranian and Pakistani contacts and cannot be independently verified.
On 15 October President Trump said he would not use nuclear weapons against Iran. Gibbs's view of what happens if a renewed strike fails is his analysis. He also sees an even greater nuclear risk in Ukraine.
The 95% and 99% figures, and the account of Iran's preparations, are the host's own sourcing from Iranian and Pakistani contacts and cannot be independently verified.
The "Mark 10" missiles mentioned at 18:30 could not be identified. The channel's public-record notes: a Tehran meeting of Iran, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Türkiye on 26 October; a Wall Street Journal report on 28 October that Gulf governments were told to prepare for a US campaign after the midterms; Israel's 27 October election left neither bloc with a majority; recent polls show 54–71% of Americans opposed to the war or saying it was not worth fighting.
Timeline:
00:10:29 The rule, not the exception: every president since 1945 but one, by Gibbs's count, had a war
00:22:46 Can't win: "There's no real strategy of victory," Gibbs says
00:27:02 Can't leave: walking away means a defeat Trump could not recover from politically
00:29:36 One man: the Constitution, the purge of generals, and who decides